This 1,700-Year-Old Song Is the Oldest Christian Music We Have

Episode Outline:

0:00 The earliest Christian hymn ever found
0:00 Breaking announcement: Biblical Studies Symposium in Denver
1:55 Intro: Charles Cosgrove on music in early Christianity
2:04 Where the hymn was found and how old it is
4:10 How we know this text is actually music
7:15 What the musical notation shows us
11:03 Who likely composed the hymn and why it was written down
15:28 How early Christians probably used music in worship and meals
17:23 How Christian music compared with pagan religious music
19:14 How scholars deciphered the hymn
20:22 How similar it is to other ancient Greek music
22:44 What the hymn says and how it has been translated
29:01 What the melody sounds like and why it feels unfamiliar
34:02 Is there any continuity between this hymn and later church music?
36:20 Where to go to learn more about early Christian music

Episode Description

Music is a cornerstone of modern Christian worship, from traditional organ-led hymns to contemporary praise bands. But what did the very first followers of Jesus sing? For centuries, the answer was lost to time, with the earliest known notated Christian music dating to the 9th-century Gregorian chants. That all changed with a stunning discovery in an ancient Egyptian garbage dump.

In this fascinating episode, host Megan Lewis is joined by Dr. Charles Cosgrove, an emeritus professor of early Christian literature and an expert in ancient music. Dr. Cosgrove walks us through the discovery and significance of the "Oxyrhynchus Hymn," a piece of music written on a papyrus fragment dated to the late 3rd century CE. Found in the trash heaps of the ancient city of Oxyrhynchus, this hymn is the single earliest piece of Christian music with musical notation in existence, predating the next known examples by over 500 years.

Dr. Cosgrove explains how we know this fragment contains music and not just a poem. Above the Greek lyrics, a separate set of characters—a system of ancient Greek musical notation using letters of the alphabet—preserves the melody and rhythm. He details how scholars can decipher these notes, allowing us to not only read the words but also hear the music as it may have sounded nearly 1,800 years ago.

The discussion then turns to the composer. While their name is lost, the hymn itself provides a compelling profile. This was no amateur. The use of complex metrical poetry and technical musical notation indicates a highly educated, professionally trained musician who was also a Christian. Dr. Cosgrove argues that the very act of writing the music down suggests it was intended for transmission—to be shared with other musicians across space and time, rather than just for the composer's personal use.

Perhaps one of the most revealing parts of the conversation is the context of its performance. Forget the image of a large congregation singing from a hymnal. Dr. Cosgrove, citing descriptions from early Christian writers like Tertullian, paints a picture of worship that was intimate and often spontaneous. Singing typically took place during communal meals, where individuals would be invited to stand and sing a solo piece "from his or her own genius." The Oxyrhynchus Hymn, therefore, was likely not a song for a full choir.

The hymn's content is a beautiful blend of Christian theology and classical Greek tradition. It begins with a "call for stillness," a common feature in pagan Greek hymns where the natural world—stars, rivers, winds—is commanded to be silent to honor the deity. Here, this classical motif is repurposed for a Christian context. The hymn then moves into a doxology of praise to the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.

Finally, Dr. Cosgrove and Megan Lewis listen to a modern performance of the hymn, discussing its unique sound. While its musical language is diatonic (using the whole-step/half-step scale familiar to Western ears), its structure is very different from modern hymns. The melody is through-composed, meaning it doesn't repeat in stanzas or verses. Instead, it weaves and wanders in a complex, non-repetitive flow, more akin to Gregorian chant than to a four-verse hymn.

Also watch these episodes:

Were Early Christians Known to Be Moral Reprobates?
Were Early Christians Known to Be Moral Reprobates?

Love Thy Stranger: The Radical Origins of Western Compassion
Love Thy Stranger: The Radical Origins of Western Compassion

Why is the Book of Revelation in the Bible?
Why is the Book of Revelation in the Bible?