A New On-Demand Course

Must Women Keep Silent?

Paul’s real views on gender, desire, and women.

Must Women Keep Silent? course art
Watch Anytime 4 Lectures Travis Proctor · Early Christianity

Which Paul Are You Reading?

Did Paul liberate women, or silence them?

Caravaggio, The Conversion of Saint Paul (1601)
The Conversion of Saint Paul Caravaggio · 1601

Ask whether the Apostle Paul freed women or silenced them, and the honest answer is: it depends which Paul you’re reading. The same tradition gives us Phoebe the deacon and Junia the apostle… and the command that women keep silent in church.

That isn’t a contradiction to explain away. It’s the whole story. In his seven authentic letters, Paul writes into real arguments about marriage, desire, veils, and who may speak in the assembly. He is, by turns, more radical and more conservative than you have been told.

Then his name took on a life of its own. Later writers signed his authority to opposite causes: the Pastoral Epistles to shut women up, the Acts of Paul and Thecla to send a woman out preaching. The Paul we argue about today is many voices at once, filtered through centuries of reception, forgery, and interpretation. Every claim on his name was also a power move: a bid for authority over what a Christian should be.

This course untangles them.

Course at a Glance

Must Women Keep Silent?

/ 01

Format

On-demand video

/ 02

Lectures

4 · 50 min each

/ 03

Access

Lifetime, watch anytime

/ 04

Instructor

Travis Proctor

/ 05

Specialty

Early Christianity & Gender

Four lectures, from the real Paul to his warring heirs.

The Lectures

From the man himself, through his most explosive letters, to the rival movements that each claimed his name on women.

Lecture I

The Apostle Paul in History and Legend

The historical Paul before the arguments begin: a Jewish Pharisee, a persecutor of the Jesus movement, and the man undone by a vision on the Damascus road. We set the stage for everything that follows, including the scholarly problem of which letters Paul actually wrote, and which only borrowed his name.

Apostle to the Gentiles
Lecture II

Neither Male nor Female

Paul’s most radical line, “there is no longer male and female” (Galatians 3:28), and the women named in Romans 16: Phoebe the deacon, Prisca the coworker, and Junia, called foremost among the apostles. Paul’s own letters hold the strongest evidence we have for female leadership in the earliest church.

Galatia and Rome
Lecture III

Better to Marry Than to Burn

A deep dive into 1 Corinthians, where Paul gives pragmatic, situational advice on marriage, abstinence, desire, divorce, and why women should veil in worship. It ends with the infamous command for women to be silent in church, and the textual problem that may mean Paul never wrote it at all.

The Crises of Corinth
Lecture IV

In Thecla’s Wake

After Paul, two movements seized his authority and pulled it in opposite directions. The Pastoral Epistles forge a stricter, patriarchal Paul who silences women. The Acts of Paul and Thecla celebrates an ascetic woman who self-baptizes, preaches, and defies the city, with Paul’s blessing. The same apostle, weaponized against himself.

The Legacies of Paul
TP
Travis Proctor Travis Proctor · 2026
Your Instructor

Travis Proctor.

Scholar of Early Christianity · Ph.D., UNC-Chapel Hill

A first-generation college graduate and scholar of the bible and early Christianity, Travis Proctor received his Ph.D. in Religious Studies from UNC-Chapel Hill, specializing in ancient Mediterranean religions. His teaching and research draw from interdisciplinary fields like religious studies, environmental history, animal studies, space and material culture, and ritual studies. His first book, Demonic Bodies and the Dark Ecologies of Early Christian Culture (Oxford University Press), explored how early Christian theorizations of demonic bodies influenced ancient understandings of cosmic “ecosystems,” and how such historical perspectives may inform contemporary environmental ethics.

His work has appeared in academic journals such as the Journal of the American Academy of Religion, Journal of Early Christian Studies, Harvard Theological Review, and the Journal of Ecclesiastical History, as well as public venues including Bible Odyssey, Religion for Breakfast, Religion Dispatches, The Bart Ehrman Blog, and the “Tell Me Something I Don’t Know” podcast. He lives in Ohio and enjoys hiking outdoors, a good round of disc golf, and watching Kansas City Chiefs football (even before Taylor Swift!)

Ph.D., UNC-Chapel HillDemonic Bodies (Oxford UP)Harvard Theological ReviewAncient Mediterranean Religions

0

Lectures

0

Authentic Letters

Lifetime Access

Why this course is unlike any other.

What This Course Offers

Travis Proctor reads the letters with you line by line, separating the historical Paul from the Paul later writers invented, so the famous verses finally make sense in their own world.

Prepare to Rethink

What everyone assumes about Paul and women… and why it’s wrong.

Common Assumption

“Paul was either a proto-feminist or a chauvinist.”

In fact

Both camps quote him with total confidence. Read the letters closely and you find a man who fits neither caricature, and the reason why is stranger than either side will tell you.

Common Assumption

“On women, the Bible (or at least Paul) speaks with one voice.”

In fact

Lay the passages side by side and something doesn’t add up. The same apostle seems to say two opposite things, and once you see why, the famous verses never read the same way again.

Common Assumption

“These verses are timeless rules for all time.”

In fact

Put them back in the room where they were written, and they start to look like answers to a very specific fight. What Paul was actually responding to may surprise you.

Common Assumption

“Women’s history runs in a straight line, from oppression to freedom.”

In fact

The Pauline story refuses to move in a straight line. Where it really goes, and who turns up preaching at the end of it, is one of the most unexpected turns in early Christianity.

Included Bonuses

Included with your course.

Course Quiz

A quiz to test and reinforce what you learn, across the letters, the women, and the contested legacy of Paul.

Lecture Slides & Recommended Readings

Download Travis’s slides for all four lectures, plus a list of recommended readings, perfect for review or to take the material further.

Audio Downloads & Transcripts

MP3 downloads and full transcripts of every lecture. Listen on the go, search the text, or follow along if English is not your first language.

$1 from every registration is donated to charity: water, bringing clean water to people in need.

2 ways to purchase this course

Stand-Alone Purchase

Enjoy the course at a fraction of the cost

Regular Price $59.95 Special Launch $47.00


Included in Your Purchase: Lifetime Access to This University-Level Course With:

  • 4 fifty-minute lectures by Travis Proctor
  • Course quiz to test what you learn
  • Lecture slides & reading guide
  • Audio downloads & full transcripts · BSA members save 30%

Access this Course PLUS Every Course in Our Vault

(250+ Hours of Biblical Learning!)

  • 50+ existing courses plus all new releases (we're aiming for 20+ new courses in 2026)
  • All "Face to Face on the Bible" events and debates
  • Bart Ehrman's monthly "Spotlight" lectures
  • Join 1,500+ members for discussion, member mixers, trivia, book club, & more!
Start FREE Trial

then special rate $49.95/month

Frequently Asked

Everything you need to know.

How many lectures are included?

Travis Proctor presents four fifty-minute lectures (on the historical Paul; Galatians and Romans; 1 Corinthians; and the contested Pauline legacy of the Pastorals and the Acts of Paul and Thecla), plus a quiz to test what you learn. The lectures are available on demand, so you can watch at your own pace.

Is this a live course?

No. This is a recorded, on-demand course. You get the full lectures to watch whenever you like, as many times as you like, plus a quiz to reinforce the material.

Do I need to be religious to take this course?

Not at all. This is a historical course, not a devotional one. Whether you’re a believer, a skeptic, or simply curious about how the Bible came to say what it says about women, you’ll find it genuinely rewarding.

How will I access the course?

Once you have purchased the course, you will receive instructions by email to log in to our online course platform, ThriveCart Learn. Once logged in, you will find all four lectures available to watch on demand. If you are a member of Biblical Studies Academy (BSA), your access will also be available inside the community.

Do I have lifetime access?

Yes. All four lectures are yours with lifetime access. You can watch them on any device, on your own schedule, and return to them as often as you like.

Do I need prior knowledge of the Bible or early Christianity?

No prior knowledge required. Travis introduces the letters, the figures, and the controversies as the course unfolds. Whether you’re coming in fresh or already have a background in biblical studies, you’ll find the course rewarding.

Will subtitles or captions be available?

Yes. All lectures include closed captions, and full transcripts are included with the course, so you can follow along in text or search for specific passages.

What payment types are accepted?

We accept PayPal and all major credit cards.

Do you offer a money-back guarantee?

Absolutely. If you don’t love the course, send us an email at support@bartehrman.com within 30 days of purchase and we will refund 100% of your investment.